मंथिकाManthika
Menu

The timetable on the board

A classroom seen from the back. The teacher stands beside a wide blank chart pinned to the board. Children whisper. Dhruv, in the second row, turns to Sameer with his brow creased.
MONDAY · The half-yearly timetable went up, and the whispering started.

Monday. The half-yearly timetable went up on the board.

Maths was the day after Hindi. The syllabus was three chapters longer than anyone thought. And a rumour: after the exams, the sections would be reshuffled.

Dhruv worried all evening. He did not open a book. “What are you doing, beta?” said Mummy. “Thinking about the exam.”

By bedtime nothing on the board had moved. Tonight’s chapter was still unread.

↑ Back to top

The idea

A LONGER LOOK

The idea

Separate what you can move, what you can only nudge, and what you can only have opinions about.

Here is what the three words mean, on Monday night.

Draw yourself as a dot. Round the dot, three rings.

The near ring is what you can move. Your hand is on it. When you move, it moves. Tonight’s chapter. The middle ring is what you can nudge. You can push, and someone else decides. The class can ask ma’am to move the Maths paper. Ma’am decides.

The far ring is what you can only have an opinion about. You can think what you like. It moves for nobody in the room. The syllabus. The exam date.

three rings
the syllabus
the Maths paper’s day
tonight’s chapter
Three rings. One thing in each.
Monday night, and the same list sorted
the syllabus
the class list
the Maths paper’s day
tonight’s chapter
Monday night, and the same list sorted. Three things far out. One under his hand.

To tell the rings apart, ask each worry one question. If I did something about it tonight, what would be different tomorrow?

Tonight’s chapter: read it, and tomorrow it is read. Near ring. The Maths paper’s day: ask, and tomorrow ma’am has heard you. Middle ring. The syllabus: nothing. Not a chapter less. Far ring.

Monday night’s list, sorted: three far out, one under his hand.

↑ Back to top

What people believe instead

A kitchen at night. Mummy rolls chapatis at the counter and looks back over her shoulder with a warm smile. Dhruv sits at the table with a closed book, chin on his hand, staring at nothing.
THE KITCHEN · “Good that you are worried, beta. It means you are doing something.”

“Good that you are worried, beta,” said Mummy, and smiled. “It means you are doing something about it.” Dhruv did not argue. It felt true.

But look where the worry put the syllabus. In the near ring, under his hand. The syllabus is in the far ring. Worry moves nothing in any ring. Only a hand in the near ring moves anything. And the chapter, which was really there, stayed unread.

as Mummy sees it, and as it is
the syllabus
the Maths paper’s day
tonight’s chapter
As Mummy sees it, and as it is. In the first picture the syllabus sits under his hand. In the real one it sits far out, and the worry is the arrow.
Dinner on the living-room floor. Papa, cross-legged, raises one palm in a calm that-is-how-it-is gesture. Veer is busy with a chapati. Dhruv listens, spoon halfway to his plate.
DINNER · “The school decides all of it, beta. Nothing is in our hands.”

At dinner Papa said the other thing. “The school decides all of it, beta. Nothing is in our hands. You just study.” Papa was right about the syllabus. But look where he put tonight’s chapter. Far out, as if the school decided that too.

It did not. The chapter is under Dhruv’s hand whatever the school decides. The Maths day can be nudged. When everything is pushed to the far ring, there is nothing left to do but worry.

as Papa sees it, and as it is
the syllabus
the Maths paper’s day
tonight’s chapter
As Papa sees it, and as it is. In the first picture everything sits far out. In the real one the chapter is still under his hand.

↑ Back to top

The class list

A sunlit school courtyard at lunch. Sameer sits at the end of a long bench with his tiffin open, grinning up. Dhruv sits down beside him, the worry gone from his face.
LUNCH · The list was far out. The bench was under his hand.

Then the rumour. If the sections were reshuffled, Sameer might land in another one. Dhruv spent a lunch break worrying about the list.

So he sorted it. The class list: far ring. Whether he and Sameer stay friends across two sections: middle ring. He can push for it, and Sameer decides too. Where he sits at lunch today: under his hand. He went and sat with Sameer.

the friends, sorted
the class list
who Sameer plays with
where I sit at lunch
The friends, sorted.

The far ring is not the ring of things that do not matter. The syllabus matters. You can think it is too long, and say so. To Mummy. To ma’am. Sorting a worry into the far ring does not throw it away. It gives the evening back, for the chapter that is there.

And where a thing sits is this year’s picture. Not for ever.

↑ Back to top

Spot it

PUZZLE CORNER

1

The school bus is late every day, and you are late for assembly. The bus route. Leaving the house five minutes earlier. Which ring is each in?

PUZZLE CORNER

2

Sports day is on Friday and the sky has been grey all week. The rain. The raincoat in your bag. Which ring?

Over Dhruv’s shoulder: a sheet of paper with a small dot near the bottom edge and three pencil half-circles round it. A few blank ovals sit inside the rings. An open book lies beside the paper.
TUESDAY NIGHT · A dot, three rings, and every worry in one of them.

Tuesday night Dhruv drew the rings on paper and put each worry in one. Then he ran his own test. What would go wrong if I stopped thinking about the exam? Nothing that was not going wrong already. So he put the syllabus down where it lived, and opened the chapter.

Here is the move. When a worry has taken the evening, draw the rings and put it in one. If it lands far out, put it down. Pick one thing from the near ring.

the two, answered
the bus route
leaving early
The two, answered. The route and the rain sit far out. Leaving early and the raincoat sit under your hand.
HANDS ON

This week, at home

Take one worry from this week. Draw the dot and the three rings. Which ring is it in? If it is the far ring, what is in the near ring instead?

↑ Back to top

The same rings, three costumes

A school sports ground under low grey clouds, a drizzle starting. A row of children in PT kit wait by the track. Dhruv, at the front, pulls a blue raincoat out of his bag and grins at the sky.
FRIDAY · The rain was far out. The raincoat was in the bag.

On Friday it drizzled on sports day. Dhruv had not spent one minute on the sky. He pulled the raincoat out of his bag and ran. The exam, the friends and sports day are one shape. A dot, three rings, and each worry in one of them. The syllabus, the class list and the rain sat far out, and moved for nobody. The chapter, the lunch bench and the raincoat sat under his hand. The evening went where his hand could go.

the same shape, three costumes
the syllabus
the paper’s day
the chapter
The same rings, three costumes. The far thing stays far; the near thing moved.
A SCHOLAR INDIA REMEMBERS

Dhruv thought of Uncle Sushruta, who sorted things before touching them. Three worries that felt like one kind: are they? Sorted, the syllabus, the paper’s day and the chapter were three things in three rings. Only one needed his hand.

↑ Back to top

The name

People who study this have a name for the near ring. They call it the circle of action. Circle: the rings drawn round you. Action: what your hands can do. Everything inside the circle of action moves when you move; everything outside it moves for someone else, or for nobody.

Separate what you can move, what you can only nudge, and what you can only have opinions about. The circle of action is the near ring.

the name, one word at a time
move
nudge
opinion
The shape with no story in it.
A LITTLE HISTORY

Where you will see this next

Next chapter: a wish is a picture, and a want says what it costs and what stands in the way. The rings come back in Class 12, wider.

↑ Back to top