मंथिकाManthika
Menu

Someone put it there

Aarav walks down a long supermarket aisle with an empty basket; far away at the end of it, a fridge of milk glows.
THE BIG SHOP · The milk is at the very back.

On Saturday, Mummy sent Aarav into the big new shop near home for one thing: a packet of milk.

The milk was at the very back. To reach it, he walked past biscuits, then chocolates, then cold drinks, then a long table of offers.

He came out with the milk and a chocolate he had not gone in for. The next Saturday, the same thing happened.

one way in, and the shortest
the way in
the shortest way
The way the shop laid out, and the shortest way to the same milk.

The milk did not end up at the back. Somebody put it there.

↑ Back to top

The idea

Aarav had walked that way ten times and never once asked why. People who study how things are made put it in one sentence.

A LONGER LOOK

The idea

Everything man-made was decided by someone, for a purpose, often not yours.

Take it one part at a time.

Man-made means made by people. Rain is not man-made. A shop is. So is a road, a queue, a game and this book.

Anything people make, somebody decided. Somebody chose where the milk goes. They could have put it by the door.

A purpose is what a thing is for. To find it, ask of each stop on the way: who is this for?

whose is each stop?
the way in
The four stops on the way to the milk, named.

The shop wants you to pass everything on the way. Some of it goes home with you. That is its purpose. It is not yours: you came for milk.

A LITTLE HISTORY

Where you saw this last

Last year: people respond to what pays them. A shop is paid when you buy, so it lays the way to make you buy.

Here is why this is hard to see. Walk the same way every week, and it stops looking decided.

It starts to look like the only way, like a hill or the rain. Nobody asks who put a hill there. So the places you know best are the hardest ones to ask about.

the same way, twice
the way in
The same way, twice: as it looks every Saturday, and as it was decided.

↑ Back to top

What people say instead

Aarav’s grandfather on a low divan raises one hand, smiling, as he explains; Aarav sits beside her, listening.
THE FRONT ROOM · Dada explains.

Aarav told Dada about the milk at the back.

Dada smiled. He did not want Aarav cross with a shop over one chocolate. “Arre, shops are like that, dikra,” he said. “Some things are just the way they are.”

Dada was right that most days nobody stops to ask who decided.

Then he laughed. When Dada was twelve, the milk came to him. “The milkman rode to our door on his cycle every morning,” he said.

three ways to the same milk
then
Three ways to the same milk, laid by three different people.

↑ Back to top

Two more ways

A single line of children stands inside new steel rails that bend along a canteen wall; Aarav, in the middle of the line, looks along the rails.
THE CANTEEN · The queue bends now.

In June, Aarav’s school put steel rails in the canteen. Now the queue bends along the wall before it reaches the counter.

“It is longer!” said his friend Irfan.

Aarav had seen this shape before, in the big shop. He asked himself: who laid this, and what for? The school laid it. The bend takes the line past the teacher on duty, so she can see every child. That purpose is the school’s.

Inside the rails, nobody can push in ahead of you. That one is yours.

one queue, laid by the school
the new queue
the shortest way
The school laid the queue. One stop is for the school, one is for you.

On Sundays, Aarav may play a game on Mummy’s old phone.

When a round ends, one big bright button starts the next one.

To stop, he taps a small grey cross. Three screens come next: “One more go?”, “Watch this for a free life” and “Are you sure?” Only then does it stop.

The people who made the game laid both ways. The way back in has no stops. The way out has three.

Nobody hides the cross. It is only further away than the button that starts the next round. Somebody decided that too.

Aarav sits on the front steps of his building holding an old phone, his thumb over the glowing screen, a little fed up.
THE FRONT STEPS · The long way out.
two ways, one maker
to play again
to stop
Two ways, both laid by the game’s makers. Only one of them is short.
A SCHOLAR INDIA REMEMBERS

Aarav’s teacher once told the class about Gautama, who taught long ago how to reason one step at a time. What do you see? What usually goes with it? Does this case fit? Aarav tried the steps on the game. A long way out usually goes with someone wanting you to stay. This one fits. He was not surer than before, only checked.

↑ Back to top

Spot it

Aarav walks down a long covered hall lined with stalls toward bright daylight at the far end, a notebook in his hand.
THE BUS STAND · A long hall to the road.

Two more ways. Ask the same two questions of each: who laid this, and what for?

PUZZLE CORNER

1

At a big bus stand, the way from the buses to the road goes through a long hall of stalls. Who laid it out that way, and what for?

PUZZLE CORNER

2

Every chapter of this book shows you a picture first and gives you the name last. Who decided that, and what for?

two ways. who laid them?
off the bus
the shortest way
Two ways, with nobody named yet.

Aarav opened his jaadu-notebook to a blank page and drew the bus stand, the long way and the short one.

He left both questions without answers for now. What would you write under each one?

↑ Back to top

Every way was laid

Beside a fridge just inside the door, a shopkeeper hands Aarav a pouch of milk across the counter.
THE CORNER SHOP · Milk by the door.
two ways, answered
off the bus
the shortest way
Both, answered. Rust stops for whoever built the bus stand; blue stops for you.

The bus stand was laid out by whoever built it. Every stall you pass pays them. That purpose is theirs.

This book was laid out too. The picture comes first so you can see a thing before you name it. That purpose is yours.

The big shop, the canteen and the game were decided the same way: by someone, for a reason. Often the reason is not yours. Not always.

Aarav looked at his notebook. Five places, one shape: a way somebody laid, with stops on it.

HANDS ON

This week, at home

Walk through one room at home or at school. Find one thing somebody put there on purpose. Ask who, and what for.

↑ Back to top

The name

Aarav sits on a low wall looking out at a busy street with a footbridge, shops and a bus shelter.
THE STREET · All of it, decided.

People who make things call this design. To design something is to decide what it will be like, and what it is for, before it is made.

Last year you met people who respond to what pays them. The people who design things are people too. So the question is always the same: designed for whom?

the shape, with no story in it
the way laid
the shortest way
The shape, with no story in it. You have seen it on every page before this one.

Aarav still buys milk at the big shop. Now he sees the chocolates for what they are: a stop somebody put on his way.

A LITTLE HISTORY

Where you will see this next

Next chapter: the things you get wrong the first time you use them. Whose mistake is that?

↑ Back to top